Skip to main content

  Anderson Cooper 360 Post Debate Special  CNN  September 16, 2015 8:00pm-10:04pm PDT

8:00 pm
means we have to vote on it, war is initiated by congress, not by the president, and that we go to war reluctantly, but then when we go to war, we don't fight with one arm tied behind our back, we fight all out to win, but then we come home. >> at the end of my presidency, i would like to believe the world would be a safe place and there wouldn't be the threats not only to the u.s., but to israel and our allies because we would have the most incredible well trained, well equipped, well prepared military in the history of mankin and they would know that the commander in chief would never send them to a mission without all the resources necessary, but people wouldn't bully us anymore. because they would know that that would be an invitation to their destruction. domestically we would be operating under a tax system that eliminated the irs, people wouldn't be punished for their work, and for what they produce ed. and life would be really deemed precious.
8:01 pm
abortion would be no more. it would be as much of a scourge in our past as slavery is. and we would have a peaceful country where people respected each other and people respected law enforcement. and we would focus on cures. and we would make this country not only safe from our enemies without, but safe from the enemies within. and it would be a good place to raise our kids and our grandkids. >> one of the things that made ronald reagan a great president is he understood that america was a unique nation, like any other that existed throughout human history. he knew it was founded on universal principles that were powerful, dignity of all people, human rights, the rights of all live to live in freedom and liberty and choose their own path in life. he didn't believe it, he acted on it. that's why bringing down communism was so important to him. if i'm honored with the opportunity to be president, i hope that our air force one will fly first and foremost to our allies in israel, south korea, japan. they know we stand with them.
8:02 pm
that america can be counted on. it would also fly to china, not just to meet with our enemies, not just to meet with those adversaries of ours that are there, but also to meet with those that aspire to freedom and liberty within china. i would even invite them to -- we would fly to moscow and russia and not just meet with the leaders of russia, but also meet with those who aspire to freedom and liberty in russia and i hope my air force one, if i become president, will one day land in a free cuba, where its people can choose its leaders and its own destiny. >> ronald reagan believed in america. if i'm elected president our friends and allies across the globe will know that we stand with them, the bust of winston churchill will be back in the oval office, and the american embassy in israel will be in jerusalem. enemies across this world will know the united states is not to be trifled with. isis will be defeated.
8:03 pm
we will have a president willing to utter the words radical islamic terrorism and the ayatollah khomeini will understand that he will never, ever, ever acquire nuclear weapons. here at home, we'll reignite the promise of america. young people coming out of school, with student loans up to their eyeballs, will find instead of no jobs, two, three, four, five job opportunities. how will that happen? through tax reform. we'll pass a simple flat tax and abolish the irs. and through regulatory reform, we will repeal every word of obama care. you want to know what i'll do as president, it is real simple. we'll kill the terrorists, we'll repeal obamacare and we will defend the constitution every sing single word of it. >> well, you know, i was a radical democrat before i started listening to ronald
8:04 pm
reagan. and he didn't sound like what they said republicans were. he sounded logical. and i hope that i sound logical also. because when i look at what is going on with the united states of america, i see a lot of things that are not logical. i see us allowing people to divide us when in fact our strength is in our unity. i see people exercising the most irresponsible fiscal habits that anyone could possibly do. and hiding it from the american people so that the majority of people have no idea what our financial situation is, so when someone comes along and says, free college, free phones, free this and that, and the other, they say, wow, that's nice, having no idea that they're destabilizing our position. and i think also that ronald reagan was a master at understanding that a pinnacle nation has to be a nation that
8:05 pm
leads, if we learn to lead in the middle east right now, a coalition will form behind us, but never do it if we just sit there and talk about it. real leadership is what i would hopefully bring to america. >> if i become president, we will do something really special. we will make this country greater than ever before. we'll have more jobs. we'll have more of everything. we were discussing disease, we were discussing all sorts of things tonight, many of which will just be words, it will just pass on. i don't want to say politicians, all talk, no action. but a lot of what we talked about is words and it will be forgotten very quickly. if i'm president, many of the things that we discussed tonight will not be forgotten. we'll find solutions. and the world will respect us. they will respect us like never before. and it will be actually a friendlier world and i have to
8:06 pm
say it is a great honor to be here tonight. >> 6 million more people are living in poverty than the day that barack obama got elected president. 6 million more people. the middle class has had declining income, workforce participation rates lower than 1977. for the first time in modern history, more businesses are failing than are being created. that is what the next president will have to deal with. and i believe we can reverse course by creating a strategy of high sustained economic growth, not the new normal of 2% that all the left says we have to get used to, but a 4% growth strategy where we reform how we tax, fix the broken regulatory system, embrace the energy revolution in our midst, fix the immigration system so we can turn it into an economic driver, deal with the structural fiscal problems that exist because of our entitlement problems that will overwhelm and create way too much debt. if we grow at 4%, people will be lifted out of poverty. the great middle that defends our country will have a chance
8:07 pm
to be able to pursue their dreams as they see fit. that should be the great challenge and the great opportunity for the next president of the united states. to forge consensus to go back to a high growth strategy and then be able to lead the world. wo without a high growth strategy, we'll never have the resources or the optimism to be able to lead the world, which the world desperately needs our leadership. >> well, i turned 13 years old two days before ronald reagan was first elected. a lot of people forget this, but just a few days before that election 1980 he was behind in the polls. and i think what changed things was people in america realized they didn't want to hear what was bad about america, they wanted to know how it was going to be better. ronald reagan wasn't just a sv republican. he was an eternal off the mipti. we need to live in a world where our children are free from the threats of radical islamic
8:08 pm
terrorism. we need to live in america where we have an economy, where everyone can live their piece of the american dream, no matter what that dream is. and we need to live in a america where we have a federal government that is not too big to fail, but ultimately small enough to succeed. where we send powers back to the states and the people. that's what i did in wisconsin. we took on the big government union bosses, the big government special interests, many of whom came in from washington, to spend millions of dollars to try and take me out because we stood up to them, we didn't back down. if you give me the chance as your next president, i won't back down any day, any way, anyhow. i'll fight and win for you and your families every single day i'm in office. >> i think what this nation can be and must be is symbolized by lady liberty and lady justice. lady liberty stands tall and strong. she is clear eyed and resolute. she doesn't shield her eyes from the realities of the world, but
8:09 pm
she faces outward into the world nevertheless as we always must. and she holds her torch high. because she knows she is a beacon of hope in a very troubled world. and lady justice, lady justice holds a sword by her side. because she is a fighter, a warrior for the values and the principles that have made this nation great. she holds a scale in her other hand, and with that scale she says all of us are equal in the eyes of god. and so all of us must be equal in the eyes of the law and the government. power full and power less alike. and she wears a blindfold. and with that blindfold she is saying to us that it must be true, it can be true that in this country, in this century, it doesn't matter who you are, it doesn't matter what you look like, it doesn't matter how you start, it doesn't matter your circumstances, here in this nation, every american's life must be filled with the possibilities that come from their god given gifts, one nation, under god, indivisible,
8:10 pm
with liberty and justice for all. >> as president, i will make this a nation that will solve problems. and how? by having the elected officials and the leaders realize they're americans before they're republicans or democrats. i did it in washington. and i've done it in ohio by having the elected officials realize that they're ohioans before anything else. secondly, i will rebuild a relationships and show the respect to our allies around the world. we have no choice but to do that. we will be stronger when we are unified. and we'll fight for freedom and for human rights. and finally, a little bit of what carly said. the people that are out there listening, america was never great because we ran america from the top down.
8:11 pm
america is great because we have run america from the bottom up where we all live in the neighborhoods. one more time in america, we need to revive the concept of citizenship, where everybody's actions make a huge difference in changing the world. we have a holocaust memorial on our state house grounds. and there is one line on there that stands out all the time. if you save one life, you've changed the world. we need to adopt that as citizens and rebuild and reinspire our country. thank you. >> i turned 18 in 1980. my first vote was for ronald reagan. boy, am i glad i did it. i think the country is too. christie presidency won't be about me. it will be about you. tonight you sit at home in your living room, frustrated that you played by the rules, you paid the taxes, you do the hard things to raise your family, you feel like america's generosity
8:12 pm
is being taken advantage of. but the system is being gained, and that you're turning out to fall further and further behind. our presidency, our presidency will be about ending that, about enforcing the law, level the playing field for everybody, and once again reward those folks who play by the rules, and think that justice means more than just the word. but it means a way of life. and i will tell you this, around the world, i will not shake hands with, i will not meet with, and i will not agree to anything with a country that says death to us and death to israel and holds our hostages while we sign agreements with them. it will be an america that will be strong and resolute and will once again be able to stick out its chest and say, we truly are the greatest nation in the world because we live our lives that way, each and every day.
8:13 pm
>> that concludes this republican presidential debate. on behalf of everyone here at cnn, we want to thank the candidates, the reagan library, and the republican national committee. thank you, also, to hugh hewitt and dana bash. the next presidential debate will be right here on cnn among the democratic candidates who will face off for the first time on october 13th. that debate, partnership with facebook, will be moderated by my colleague anderson cooper. and anderson picks up our coverage of tonight's debate right now. before i throw to anderson, one final round of applause for the candidates. [ applause ] anderson? >> jake, thanks very much. when an evening. good evening from the spin room as we continue to look at the candidates on the stage. no doubt they'll be greeting their families who have been listening closely in the reagan library. it is not over yet. the candidates still on stage. president reagan's air force one the backdrop. incredible exchange over the last three hours. we'll be talking shortly with a
8:14 pm
number of the candidates tonight as we watch their families start to meet up with them. we'll talk to as many of the debaters you see now. we'll bring you the high points, the fireworks, fact checking, the talking points, getting some really fascinating real time audience reaction, breaking it all down for you over the next two hours. and if you missed some parts of this debate, we're going to be showing you the key moments throughout this debate. there you see donald trump, greeting some of his supporters, here in the spin room with amanda carpenter, former communications director for senator ted cruz. i'm here also with jeffrey lord, served as white house political director in the reagan administration, now supports donald trump. and ana na vovarro who supportsb bush. gloria borger, john king, host of inside politics and david axelrod, former top adviser to president obama. david axelrod, some quick thoughts. >> well, one thought is these people have an iron constitution
8:15 pm
to be standing there for as long as -- >> hot up there. a lot of sweating. three hours. >> it was. it was a gauntlet they ran up there. i would say one thing is that car carly fiorina had a great opportunity tonight. she took full advantage of it. she's going to move up in the polls as a result of this. chris christie was on the verge of falling off the stage, had a very strong night, very strong performance tonight. >> let's listen in to donald trump. chris, go ahead. >> thank you for joining us after speaking to your family. what did they say to you about how you were tonight? >> they were very proud and very happy and it was a beautiful time. i had an amazing time. three hours is probably a record-setting long debate. but i guess you're sell a lot of commercials during that. because they increased it, supposed to be two, but they were very professional the way they handled it. cnn did a very good job. >> we agree about that. seems like it was well run. a lot to talk about. who do you think came out on top with the best ideas for the american people? >> i think everybody did well.
8:16 pm
nobody did poorly. i think everybody did very well. i was very impressed. >> anybody more than anybody else? >> i don't want to say that. i think certain people did really well. i would never say that of course. >> carly fiorina is getting good buzz coming out of the debate. >> i think she's a very nice person. i think that really i think everybody did very well, chris. >> do you feel that you did something differently tonight than you did in the first debate? >> no, i think probably the first debate went very well for me also. they both went very well. they're saying very nice things. i heard a couple of people come over and say, wow, that was great. i think i'm very happy with both performances actually. >> there seemed to have been more discussion among the candidates during the breaks and afterwards here in this debate than in the first one. >> i think that's true. we're getting to know each other a little bit. it is quite tough and sometimes a little nasty, we're getting to know each other and, you know, you develop relationships. i have a lot of respect for a lot of people on the stage. >> what have you learned after tonight?
8:17 pm
>> well, i've learned that i have no trouble standing for three hours. and, you know, that's -- literally it must be a record. i hope that the audience is okay. i actually think it is a little bit too long. but i learned that we have a lot of talent in the republican party and i think we'll do very well come election day. >> when you look to your left and look to your right tonight, did you still feel you stand above those who else would want the job? >> i never say that. i would never say that i do. i think i'll do a great job. i think i'll be the greatest jobs producer that there ever has been in this country. i know exactly what to do. that's what i do do. cnn did a poll. i was number one in terms of leadership, number one in terms of the economy and jobs. and i don't mean number one by a little bit. you know the poll very well, by many times and i think i would certainly do an unbelievable job of putting the country back to work and literally i think people would be extremely happy and extremely proud of our country. >> can you point to anything that you heard tonight where you listened and thought, you know what, i like that idea?
8:18 pm
i think i'll use that? >> i heard a lot of things. we'll discuss it on your show at length. i have a whole family over here. >> have to process. what do you do next? >> i'm getting on the plane, we'll go back to new york and then i'm going up to new hampshire tomorrow afternoon and going to iowa. i'm going all over the place. we're having a lot of fun. the polls have been amazing. amazing. the receptivity has been so incredible. in dallas we sold out the mavericks arena. we were in alabama, mobile, alabama. had 31,000 people. the response has been incredible. they like what i'm saying. they agree with what i'm saying. >> what does it mean to have your family in the crowd, your daughter, your son? >> it is great to have them. they seem to be so receptive today. they liked -- i could see they were giving me high five sign. >> ivanka must have liked it when you said she should be on the $10 bill. >> she sat for a long time tonight. we had a good time. i was impressed with everybody. >> so if tomorrow after the pundits discuss and the polls come out and they say trump is on top, will you be surprised?
8:19 pm
>> i wouldn't be. i think i did very well. i think everybody did well. i think i did very well. >> gave enough meat on the bones? >> i think so, yeah. >> thank you for talking to us. good luck going forward. >> thank you. >> anderson, there you have it. mr. trump, everybody is working the room up here. there has been a lot more discussion among them than we have seen in the past. >> yeah. and that, david axelrod, was the question. could donald trump handle more discussion between the candidates? >> yeah. first of all, let me say for a guy who says he's not a politician, he sure reads a lot of polls. he quotes a lot of polls. but in terms of -- i don't think he was particularly specific tonight. but what he did do is bang the drum again on the issues that are driving his base on immigration in particular, on some tax issues that are driving his base. i think he did what he wanted to do. i also think he was a little bit more subdued than he's been in the past. he started the debate inexplicably slapping rand paul gratuitously who wasn't even in the discussion. then he calmed down and it
8:20 pm
seemed over the course of the three hours that he settled into a rhythm. i actually thought he did what he had to do. >> amanda carpenter, former spokesperson for ted cruz, who do you think he did? >> i think senator cruz used his time very effectively. if you look at the debates going into the senate in september, particularly, iran, and planned parenthood. he spent a lot of time on those issues because he has a very effective platform to fight on them, show them he can be effective and show that he's fighting in a way that other people can't and won't. so that was a good use of his time. as for donald trump, i think it is very interesting, tonight was an endurs teance test. i noticed throughout the debate as the discussion became more substantive, he faded away. i think he recognized that. you can see him being a little bit -- a glimmer of humility tonight. >> i think as the discussion got more substantive on foreign policy, marco rubio really was quite forceful.
8:21 pm
i think he distinguished himself. i think chris christie also managed to get into the discussion very forcefully. and scott walker actually did himself some good tonight. >> and i think speaking of scott walker, does chris have scott walker? let's -- as soon as he does, let me know. john king, for you, what were the moments. >> trump was a less dominating presence in the fox debate. he was a presence tonight. >> didn't make any mistakes. >> to david's point, he meade ky points with his constituency. around the country if you look at the twitter feeds, reaching out to conservatives in key states, there is a debate about whether he hauurt himself by gog after george w. bush. rare he comes up in a positive way in a republican primary, but the exchange with jeb bush about george w. bush kept us safe, there is a conversation about that, as to whether that could have possibly hurt donald trump.
8:22 pm
the buzz about carly fiorina is very strong. a lot of people think she may have taken some of ben carson's votes tonight. marco rubio getting points among conservatives. he seems to be among a lot of conservatives the fallback guy as the race shakes out. one last point, among conservatives who said scott walker better show up tonight, they're not saying he won the debate, but he was much more of a presence tonight. >> i'll tell you tv. >> we got to take a quick break. we'll continue the conversation throughout the next two hours. next moderator, jake tapper, joins us with dana bash and hugh hewitt on their experience down there in the fray. we'll be right back. people don't have to think about
8:23 pm
8:24 pm
where their electricity comes from. they flip the switch-- and the light comes on. it's our job to make sure that it does. using natural gas this power plant can produce enough energy for about 600,000 homes. generating electricity that's cleaner and reliable, with fewer emissions-- it matters. ♪
8:25 pm
8:26 pm
welcome back. candidates continue to make their way from the debate hall, coming into the spin room. we're going to hear from more throughout the next 90 minutes or so, rand paul, you see dr. ben carson already in the spin room. meanwhile, let's bring in wolf blitzer. wolf? >> anderson, thank you. if anyone other than the candidates themselves knows just what it was like to be on that stage for nearly three hours, whether the debaters did a good job answering very tough questions, it is our three people who are with me now, on the stage asking those questions. the conservative radio talk show host hugh hewitt, our own dana
8:27 pm
bash, and debate moderator jake tapper. you were on the stage for a lot longer. you had an earlier piece as well. how do you feel? >> depleted. >> dana? >> ditto. >> ernie banks, let's play two. >> play two more? you guys did an excellent job. let's talk about the substance. what did you think? who came away impressive, somebody who is going to maybe break out of the 15-member pack? >> i think it is, first of all, i think we all agree, it is very difficult to do punditry while trying to balance and herd the cats as we were this evening. we tried to be as even with the time as we could. i certainly think that people got to hear a lot more of ben carson this evening than they had in previous outings because he has risen to the second spot. and i heard very forceful, you know, approaches from, you know, marco rubio, chris christie, carly fiorina made her presence
8:28 pm
felt. >> did some come over to you and complain they were getting enough time. >> the daughter of one did but i won't name names because, you know -- >> it happens. >> it is her dad. >> yeah. >> what did you think, dana? what struck you as really important? >> they all came to play. they really did. and, you know, you could really feel it, i'm sure you can see it so much on camera, but you could feel it on the stage. everybody was kind of trying to get jake's eye, trying to get our eye, trying to get in, which was evident that they all -- they want -- they understood that they needed to make a mark, some of them i think maybe did more than others. but that was definitely the dynamic and i totally agree with you about carly fiorina. the one thing that struck me because i was sitting there thinking what is my takeaway towards the end, all of a sudden chris christie is this conservative. where does that come from? i'm not saying wasn't conservative before, but he was thought of as more mainstream in the republican movement. and he -- every question you asked, i asked, you asked, he fell over himself to try to move
8:29 pm
to the right. >> i'll tell you one thing, we all signaled in our interviews and everything that we wanted them to debate. that we wanted them to have exchanges with each other and disagree and, you know, we honed our questions accordingly to bring out differences between, for instance, chris christie and rand paul on marijuana and recognizing state laws or not. and for the most part, i think most of the candidates except for the ones who are naturally against insulting or attacking, most of them did that. >> even those who didn't want to do so personally, which is completely fine, i actually thought that, i mean, you especially, jake, you were able to get them going and debating on the issues that the republican voters are going to go to the polls. >> the research was terrific. you had all the evidence, where they disagree on substace and this, hugh, after all, was a debate. wasn't simply some sort of q&a. it was a debate. >> i'm a conservative. i'm happy. i don't think any one of them
8:30 pm
could complain about the time or the question selection. i think they'll all be very satisfied they had an opportunity to make a statement, and i think you're going to see unfortunately for people who want a smaller stage, i don't think anyone is going to fall off. i think everyone had moments. i think there was a great deal of energy at our end of the line. that might be physics because we're closer to governor christie, carly fiorina. maybe at the other end, less energy, marco rubio bloomed a few times. >> let me play one exchange you had and we'll discuss. listen to this. >> i'll ask you about this. in an interview last week in "rolling stone" magazine, donald trump said the following about you quote, look at that face, would anyone vote for that. mr. trump later said he was talking about your persona, not your appearance. please feel free to respond when you think about his persona. >> you know, it is interesting to me, mr. trump said that he
8:31 pm
heard mr. bush very clearly and what mr. bush said. i think women all over this country heard very clearly what mr. trump said. >> i think she's got a beautiful face. and i think she's a beautiful woman. >> all right. that was a moment, shall we say, wasn't it? >> yeah, i mean, we all wondered was she going to take the quote and express offense. what was she going to do with it? and she chose to do less is more. she did the same after -- pardon me, the water went down the wrong pipe. >> dana, you weigh in. you're a woman. what did you think of donald trump's reaction. >> thank you for clarifying
8:32 pm
that, both of you. and you're a man. i think that just for women out there, they got it. just like you were trying to say, less is more, from her perspective. you don't need to go too far to make your point and she did it with an economy of words. i think it was inconsiderably powerful. >> hugh? >> brevity is sometimes very powerful and that was useful, very powerful use of brevity. it is tricky in a debate setting to get time back to the court. sm sometimes you get punished for it. i think she'll be rewarded because it was clearly a harpoon and it stuck. >> on the other candidate that we're all watching for specifically was jeb bush who has been sinking in the polls. was he going to bring it and have energy? he did. i think he had as much as he could. and i thought at the end, your question about what your secret service code name was, the fact he came up with the name of a battery and he said, you know, everready. i don't know if you could see on camera, but he and donald trump
8:33 pm
high fived on that. >> it was interesting. i think a lot of them came here determined, pardon me. to step up their game. you saw that with scott walker. you saw with carly fiorina. you saw that with jeb bush. rand paul and chris christie kind of already have been there, already been in the position of wanting to enter the fray. but those three, i think did up their game. >> i they think they all came r. they were prepared. they showed what they wanted to do but ready to exchange different ideas with their rivals. >> cnn telegraphed they were going to have jake and dana and i set it up so they could talk to each other and they were ready to do that and they did not hesitate to do that and it was wonderful. from the perspective of a republican primary voter to see them interact that way, not back and forth between the panelists and the candidates. the candidates got into it. and i think that serves the party and conservatives very well across a broad spectrum of issues. >> i would like to say one thing. we had a lot of questions we
8:34 pm
didn't get to ask. >> really? >> yes, some of the exchanges went on long. and i just -- there were two subjects in particular that i really -- i wish -- it is hard to argue that the debate should have been longer, but i wish we had gotten to and one of the reasons we didn't really -- one of the reasons they were among the first to fall were they weren't -- they didn't bring out a lot of conflict between the candidates, and one of them is the va and how to treat veterans. and what can be done about it. and the truth is there really isn't a lot of policy difference between them. you can have one of them criticize dr. carson's plan to fold the va into the pentagon but didn't seem like an area where there would be a lot of friction. and the other one is black lives matter. there isn't really a lot of difference on the stage when it comes to that. but those are two issues that -- in a way that i wish we would have had time, but it is hard to argue that any of the good exchanges we had should have been cut. >> there will be several more republican debates.
8:35 pm
presumably these issues will come up. >> the world is on fire. iran and syria, it got the appropriate amount of time tonight, lengthy, detailed, energetic, and i think serves the purpose here. >> they grabbed those moments. >> stand by. back to anderson. he has more on what's going on. >> wolf, thank you very much. tonight ohio governor john kasich was not playing to a hometown audience like at the last debate in cleveland. a monmouth university poll put had him in third place in new hampshire with 11 h% behind dond trump and dr. kasich joins me n. how did you feel about your own debate performance and standing out there for three hours, how did it feel out there? >> look, i just wanted to be myself. i got up on the stage. i really didn't have any nerves at all, anything bothering me and, you know, you always wish you could get a little bit more time. few more things you would like to say. but all and all, i think it was
8:36 pm
a good experience and it certainly was a lot of fun and memorable. >> when you look at the field, particularly donald trump who has a lead in the polls, do you think any numbers or anybody standing really changed tonight? somebody going up or somebody going down? >> well, you know, i'm not a prognosticator, anderson. look, the bottom line is, in the early states, you have to be on the ground. you take new hampshire, you have to do town hall meetings, people want to see you, they want to question you, and it is very, very grassroots oriented. so in terms of national polls or all of that, that's not the way we elect the president. we do it state by state, early states, and i'm building and doing those things in those states, and, you know, the one thing i wanted to stress tonight was my record. i really know how to land the plane. and get the passengers on the ground because there is a lot of promises, a lot of things that don't happen. i've done these things like balancing a federal budget and balancing the budget in ohio and
8:37 pm
driving real change. that was one thing i wanted to get across. i hope i did. >> a lot of people believe you appeal to the same voters perhaps as jeb bush, establishment conservative, how did you think he did, as compared to you? >> i thought he did fine. you know, it is really hard when you're on the stage because you try to concentrate, but, you know, i'll give everybody an a, how 's that? is that politically correct? i thought everybody did fine. >> you had strong disagreements tonight with senator cruz, specifically on the issues of iran and planned parenthood. did you feel you were able to explain your stance on these issues? >> well, i hope so. look, i don't want to fund planned parenthood. i think shutting the government down when you have a president that says i'm not going to put up with it is not the right way to go. we ought to send this some bills. he wants a veto, that's fine. that's different than shutting
8:38 pm
the government down. in terms of iran, all i tried to say is that we need to watch this agreement, we need to hold these folks accountable in iran. if they violate anything, sanctions go back on, and we can make the case to our allies. if we think they're developing a nuclear weapon, get that information, if i were president, military action would clearly be on the table. >> governor kasich, appreciate your time tonight. thank you very much. just ahead, reaction from voters to what they saw tonight and more of the most important moments from tonight's three-hour long gop debate.
8:39 pm
8:40 pm
8:41 pm
my name is chris hughes and i am a certified arborist for pg&e. i oversee the patrolling of trees near power lines and roots near pipes and underground infrastructure. at pg&e wherever we work, we work hard to protect the environment. getting the job done safely so we can keep the lights on for everybody. because i live here i have a deeper connection to the community. and i want to see the community grow and thrive. every year we work with cities and schools to plant trees in our communities. the environment is there for my kids and future generations. together, we're building a better california. i was going to the library to do my homework. it was a little bit of a walk to get to the bus stop. i had to wait in line to use the computer. took a lot of juggling to keep it all together. what's possible when you have high-speed internet at home? the library never closes.
8:42 pm
it makes it so much better to do homework when you're at home. internet essentials from comcast. helping to bridge the digital divide. welcome back. randi kaye is in des moines, iowa, tonight at break university where she watched the debate with a group of undecided voters. what are you hearing from them? >> we're hearing a lot of feedback. there was some cheers, some boos during the debate. 32 undecided voters here at cole's library at drake university. let's talk to a couple of them. first of all, angela, you had pretty much written off chris christie, but tonight you were impressed. >> i was impressed. but to go from written off to probably a two or a three. so -- >> why do you think he did a
8:43 pm
good job? >> i think he brought a lot of specifics. i was impressed with some of the facts, you know, we're looking for facts, not just thoughts hour high level ideas and i think he did bring some facts to the table. you know. so he moved up a little. but -- >> the group wants specifics, for sure. anderson, a lot of the people here think that carly fiorina was a big standout, including susan here. why do you think carly did such a good job? >> i think she took on donald trump. he did not impress me as much as he has in the past. but carly was there. she was steadfast. she was intelligent. she was -- she just really came across as someone that thought things through more than, you know, spoke off the cuff. she's an outsider. i think that we have in the last election cycle handed the republicans a pretty big
8:44 pm
majority and they have done nothing with it. so i'm looking at an outsider. >> how do you think, mike, donald trump did tonight and ben carson since they're neck and neck? >> i'm not a supporter of them. i don't think they did themselves any favors. ben carson is a nice guy, well informed, but doesn't have the background and experience. and donald is donald. >> one thing, anderson, the entire group here, 100% think the country is going in the wrong direction. i'm going to hand it off to bob there quickly in the back. can you tell us why you think along with this group that the country is just headed in the wrong direction? >> i think the federal government is taking us in the wrong direction. i think they think short-term as opposed to long-term. short-term is the next election. the next fund-raiser. let's get elected. let's get somebody to agree with us. this is a tough business to run the government. >> absolutely. thanks to all of you here. that's just a small sampling of the various opinions here at our
8:45 pm
focus group at drake university, anderson. >> thank you very much for that. thank everybody for participating there. back with our panel. you're a supporter of jeb bush. how do you think he did. his pac will start to spend a lot of money. he did break out tonight? >> i think he had a very good debate. he had solid answers. his answers get -- they're going to prove out to be true. he had some memorable moments. he showed a sense of humor, and actually worked. he apologized to his mom for having smoked pot. i think we'll remember that. he had that exchange with donald trump where they wound up high fiving each other. when it was about what the secret service code name was going to be. i also think he did a strong defense of his wife, strong defense of his brother. i thought jeb brought it, he was
8:46 pm
much better than in cleveland, that's, i think what people are going to measure him for. >> let's play -- >> marco was i thought exceptional thinking about policy. >> marco rubio. let's play an exchange where jeb bush tried to take on donald trump and particularly the one you referenced where he talked about his wife because the question was about some comments that donald trump tweeted about, including jeb bush's wife in that. let's play that exchange. >> governor bush, mr. trump has suggested that your views on immigration are influenced by your mexican-born wife. he said that, quote, if my wife were from mexico, i think i would have a soft spot for people from mexico. did mr. trump go too far in invoking your wife? >> he did, he did. you're proud of your family, just as i am. >> correct. >> to subject my wife into the middle of a raucous political conversation was completely inappropriate and i hope you apologize for that, donald. >> i hear phenomenal things.
8:47 pm
i hear your wife is a lovelyshe. she is the love of my life and you should apologize to her right now. >> they come into our country as an act of love. with all of the problems that we have in so many instances, we have wonderful people coming in. but with all of the problems, this is not an act of love. he's weak on immigration. by the way, in favor of common core, which is also a disaster. but weak on immigration. he doesn't get my vote. >> jeffrey lord, did jeb bush, ana navarro said he had a good debate, did he do enough? >> i'm not sure he did. one of the problems this bush has, this is something that john was just saying a few minute s ago, about the controversy over george w. bush and donald trump, et cetera, there is what i call the reagan/bush divide. if you notice the other day, jeb
8:48 pm
bush unbuttoned his shirt and had a reagan/bush '84 shirt. i was in that campaign. and there was always this little subrose of attention there, a first cousin to the outsider, insider debate. you got a lot of conservatives out there who are upset with george w. bush, not just over iraq, but they're upset about domestic spending. upset about domestic policies here. that is a real problem here. and i think when you see jeb sort of deal with this kind of thing, this is all about my wife, it is really about much more than that. and, you know -- >> amanda? >> i think the most interesting subtext with jeb bush in this debate is his new found willingness to defend his family. his best moment of the debate, i think, is when he came out and reminded everyone that his brother kept america safe. on the same hand, i think that will haunt him long-term because tying hmmself to his brother's legacy is bad in the long run. for this performance, that was
8:49 pm
an important moment. >> let's play that moment and talk to this side. >> your brother and your brother's administration gave us barack obama because it was such a disaster those last three months that abraham lincoln couldn't have been elected. >> you know what, as it relates to my brother, there is one thing i know for sure, he kept us safe. i don't know if you remember. you remember the -- you remember the rubble? you remember the firefighter, with his arms around it? he sent a clear signal that the united states would be strong and fight islamic terrorism and he did keep us safe. >> does jeb bush get out of single digits? >> well, we don't know. i think he was stronger tonight than he has been in the past. i think the other republican candidates, by the way, defended w. when it came to national security saying, well, it was barack obama who gave us -- gave
8:50 pm
us the rise of isis. >> as did the audience. >> it was a republican audience. the person i think who didn't do himself any favors here tonight was dr. carson. you didn't hear a lot substantive from him. hes with kind of quiet as we have seen. and i thought that he and trump might engage each other a little bit more. and i think there was kind of a mutual detente. >> dr. carson, he questioned trump's faith he walked it back and apologized. david, you think that perhaps the gop in focusing so extensively on legal legal immigratii -- illegal immigrations -- >> the party did a retrospective on the campaign and said we have to do better in reachi hispanics, to women, to young people. this is not the debate the party
8:51 pm
wants to have geei ingoing into election. it is problematic spending all that time on planned parenthood, which has great support among the broader electorate, particularly among women, spending all that time on immigration and competing with each other to get to the right of each other. this is a repeat of what we saw in 2012. one of the reasons why reince priebus was so eager to limit the number of debates and try and control them. i think plainly he hasn't been successful. >> however, the fact of the matter is they're competing in a republican primary. we are four months from the iowa caucuses, which has a very conservative evangelical dominated electorate. to david's point, we'll see how this plays out when we get to the general election. >> but mitt romney -- >> talk too much about government -- >> mitt romney will attest to the fact when he talked about it in the primary it lived to haunt him in the general. it lived to haunt him in the
8:52 pm
general. >> that haunted mitt romney because it was the nominee who said it. it if trump doesn't end up being the nominee, i don't think the things that trump has been saying are going to haunt marco rubio, lindsey graham, jeb bush. >> the bush legacy, did he keep -- did george w. keep us safe? yes. on the other hand, he left the presidency according to "the new york times"/cbs poll, there is the problem, right there. >> and so you have these candidate triesing to establish their lanes tonight. i think that most of the buzz seems to be that fiorina did the best. trump did okay. carson was a little missing. i thought what was fascinating was the back and forth with governor kasich, governor bush, governor christie, the guys saying, look, it is great what you're saying but someone has to put their hand on the bible and govern on day one.
8:53 pm
reach deals to get anything done. watching them trying to establish their face. one of them will still be standing. >> they weren't fighting with each other. >> but trying to convince their slice of the electorate. they're trying to -- jeb bush's philosophy and john kasich believes the same thing, christie to a lesser degree, the republican party has moments of pat beau canuchanan comes along still believe in the end the party will come back to the establishment guy and this is all -- >> what is interesting to me is when they introduced themselves, rand paul introduced himself as an eye doctor from kentucky. you don't ahave to have 20/20 vision to know he's a senator as well. washington was a big loser in this debate for sure. >> how big a mistake was it for donald trump to come back to carly fiorina and say --
8:54 pm
>> beautiful. >> you have a beautiful face. >> first rule of law, stop digging. it was so patronizing. >> i thought it was brilliant because he -- he surprised us with his answer. >> but he didn't apologize. >> but he shut it down. >> i don't think he did. >> we have to take a break. fact checking the candidates tonight. ben carson joins us ahead at the top of the hour. we'll be right back. big day? ah, the usual. moved some new cars. hauled a bunch of steel. kept the supermarket shelves stocked.
8:55 pm
made sure everyone got their latest gadgets. what's up for the next shift? ah, nothing much. just keeping the lights on. (laugh) nice. doing the big things that move an economy. see you tomorrow, mac. see you tomorrow, sam. just another day at norfolk southern.
8:56 pm
8:57 pm
i'm a gas service rep for pg&e in san jose.. as a gas service rep we are basically the ambassador of the company. we make the most contact with the customers on a daily basis. i work hand-in-hand with crews to make sure our gas pipes are safe. my wife and i are both from san jose. my kids and their friends live in this community. every time i go to a customer's house, their children could be friends with my children so it's important to me. one of the most rewarding parts of this job is after you help a customer, seeing a smile on their face. together, we're building a better california. without the internet i would probably be like a c student. internet essentials from comcast has brought low-cost high speed internet into the homes of hundreds of thousands of low-income families. it lets students do homework and study at home. so far more than two million people across america have benefitted. internet essentials is going to transform the lives of families. i see myself as maybe an entrepreneur. internet essentials from comcast. helping to bridge the digital divide.
8:58 pm
we're approaching the top of the hour at the reagan library. 11 candidates, one stage, three hours. it was an extraordinary evening. the candidates had plenty of time to challenge their opponents, face to face, on the issues, and they certainly did repeatedly. three hours of claims, counterclaims, and more than one competing versions of some of them have said and done in the past. i'm joined right now by dr. ben carson. first of all, i was going to say three hours must have been grueling. you're a surgeon, you spend 20 hours on your feet. so how was it? >> well, it went by pretty fast, actually. i was surprised. and, you know, we would all like to have a little more time to explain our positions, but, you know, considering there are 11
8:59 pm
people on the stage, i think it went reasonably well. there were times when the moderators seemed to lose control of what was going on, but -- >> on the campaign trail, several days ago, you were asked by reporters and you talked to -- made critical comments about -- or some beliefs about donald trump's faith, you later apologized for that. there were opportunities where you could have attacked donald trump had you wanted to. you did not choose to do that. is that something you thought about a lot going into the debate? >> i'm not generally someone who attacks other people, out of general principle. i would much rather talk about what the problems are and what the solutions are. that's the way i've been for decades now. i'm probably never going to be the guy you want when you want a big fight. >> was there -- was there a moment that stood out to you in the debate, whether it was something you said or something you heard elsewhere on that stage? >> i really wanted to get
9:00 pm
included in the discussion about putin. and what we should be doing. i was looking for an opportunity to talk about, you know, our electric grid, our electric grid and cybersecurity and our lack of participation in space and what the implications are for that and the secure of the the nation. because i think those are huge issues in terms of our safety and what's going to happen with our children and grandchildren. but the opportunity just didn't present itself. >> where terms of where you see this campaign going, you're behind donald trump, one of the few in dougt digits, in terms of your organizational structure, that's what some on or abouts said look, you don't have the organizational structure at this point to get to the next level that you need to get.
9:01 pm
how actively are you working on that? is that a concern for you? i know people very underestimating you all along. >> i will say at some point they'll get tired of being wrong. obviously we have a good organizational structure. reporter who initially made that accusation has subsequently said he was wrong. >> carly fiorina, the first time she was on the stage. a lot of people saying she really did make a mark tonight. as a candidate, how do you see her from what you' heard tonight? >> i've known carly for almost 20 years and she did not disappoint. she's very, very good, particularly at the quick sound bite. and she's quick on her feet. and one of the reasons that i insisted early on that she be included is because i knew she
9:02 pm
would have an impact. >> one of the exchanges you had about donald trump is about vaccines. i want to play that for our viewers. >> i'm in favor of vaccines, do them over a longer period of time. the same amount in smaller sections. i think you're going to see a big impact on autism. >> dr. carson, you just heard his medical take. >> he's an okay doctor. but the fact of the matter is we have extremely well documented proof that there's no autism associated with vaccinations. but it is true that we are probably giving way too many in too short a period of time. and a lot of pediatricians now recognize that, and i think are cutting down on the number and
9:03 pm
proximity in which those are done. >> and that's all i'm saying, jake. that's all i'm saying. >> first of all, you saying he's an okay doctor. that's a reference to something he called you. a clever way of pushing back on it without pushing back. it doesn't -- at the end of that, it sounded like you two weren't for apart on this issue. do you think that's accurate? >> well, on the issue of too many vaccinations in too close a period of time, that's what he was agreeing with. and that's a reasonable position to take. and one of the positions i was saying is there's vaccines that are very critical to public health. there are others that, you know, they're nice but they're not critical. and i think it would be useful for us to differentiate the two. and, dwrou know, not impose the ones that aren't absolutely critical. >> your campaign manager was on
9:04 pm
scene saying the philosophy of him and the rest of the campaign is let dr. carson be dr. carson. is that moving forward with you. is he plugging away? >> as i go around the country helping people so understand what our fiscal condition is, which is very serious. i was quite disappointed that we didn't get into that at all. that's a huge issue in terms of the civility of this nation. >> it's always a pleasure. thank you, sir. appreciate it. >> just past the top of the hour now. before we bring in the panel, there are some highlights from a very big night. >> first of all, rand paul shouldn't even be on this stage. he's number 11. he has 1% on the poll, and how he got up here, there's far too many people anyway. >> i think his visceral response to attack people on their appearance, short, tall, fat,
9:05 pm
ug ugly. my goodness, that happened in junior high. >> i never attacked him on his look. and believe me, there's plenty of subject matter right there. >> you've got hillary clinton to go to your wedding because you gave her money. >> i was a businessman. i got along with clinton. i got along with everybody. that was my job, to get along with everybody. excuse me, one second. >> no, the simple fact is you could not take -- >> more energy tonight, i like that. >> you better be able to lead our country the first day in office. our president could very well confront a national security dries sis and a president better be up to date on his first day in office or her first day in office pop i'm not sure we need half a billion dollars in women's health issues. he said he misspoke. you said that's going to haunt him. >> i think it's a terrible statement. i think it's going to haunt him absolutely. why did you say it? why did you say it? i heard it myself. >> we need to increase child support with a broken system by 90% -- >> you said women's health
9:06 pm
issues. you said it. you said it. >> ms. fiorina, i do want to ask ask you about this. in an interview, donald trump said the following about you, quote, look at that face. would anyone vote for that? can you imagine that? the face of our next president. mr. trump later said he was talking about your persona, not your appearance. please feel tree to respond what you think about his persona. >> you know, it's interesting to me, mr. trump said that he heard mr. bush very clearly in what mr. bush said. i think women all over this country heard very clearly what mr. trump said. [ applause ] >> i think she's got a beautiful face and i think she's a beautiful woman. >> i haven't had an opportunity to weigh in on foreign policy,
9:07 pm
and i just want to mention that when the war -- when the issue occurred in 2003, i suggested to president bush that he not go to war, okay? so i just want that on the record. >> you were forced to file for bankruptcy, not once, not twice, four times. a record four times. why should we trust you to manage your fans in this nation any differently than you manage the finances of your casino. >> this personal back and forth about the history of donald and caly's career, for the 55-year-old construction worker in the audience tonight who doesn't have a job who can't file his child's education they could careless about your careers. >> we could see how many people smoked pot in high school. >> 40 years ago, i smoked marijuana. i admit it. other people may not want to say it. my mom is not happy that i just did. that's true.
9:08 pm
>> i'm in favor of vaccines, do them over a longer period of time, same amount, but just in little sections. dr. carson, you just heard his medical take. >> he's an okay doctor. >> what would you want your secret service code name to be? >> eveready, it's very high energy, donald. >> mr. trump? >> humble. >> that's a good one. >> just some of the moments and themes we'll be talking about tonight with host of the cnn program varying his name. also senior political reporter
9:09 pm
joins us. cnn national security commentator, mike rodgers. obviously a former republican congressman who chaired the house intelligence committee. also joining us, kevin madden, seen a cnn political commentator as well. just quickly go around. van, your thoughts on who stood out? >> well, carly had a tremendous night. she'll be up five points. i just think that she wanted the ball, she fought for the ball, she got the ball. jeb actually humanized himself. he talked about his brother, stood up for his brother. not necessarily politically smart. he talked about hi mom and he talked about his desire to do well for the country. i thought jeb bush actually humanized himself tonight. rubio put in a good performance, but carly was the standout. >> i agree. it's really hard to meet very high expectations. i thought she beat them. she came in with encredibly high
9:10 pm
expectations. she performed incredibly well, she was quick on her feet. i like what she did. every opportunity she got, she laid out incredibly substantive policy points. they weren't even asked for and she went -- she knew how valuable her time was. she wasn't going to use it with platitudes. she was going to use it with policy points that i don't think any of the other candidates matched. and frankly weren't even demanded. >> she definitely came into this well prepared with some definite ideas in mind with how to make her mark. >> absolutely. the policies really stood out. we're definitely going to see headlines that carly was a big winner. i also think rubio. he had a similar trstrategy of really showing he was the better candidate on some of the big issues they care about. namely i thought they stood out on national security and foreign policy. the other headline is that trump actually -- he took some punches tonight.
9:11 pm
he was knocked down a peg. i think the big question for a lot of these campaigns in the next day is do we put our boot on his neck or do we let him off? and so that will be interesting to see what they do. >> do you think he was really knocked down among the numbers of people who -- >> i think he did enough to help with some of those sup showing support right now. i think for the other campaigns who have been dancing around him and not sure how to hit them, i think they saw him like a boxer who finally bled for the first time. i think they're going to continue to get more and more aggressive as this campaign starts to go. >> do you agree with that? do you think that it was the length of time, it was the fact that you could get kind of specific on policy because you had candidates talking to each other? >> and trump clearly had trouble on national security and foreign policy issues. you could tell he didn't have a comfort zone there. he got himself in a little bit of trouble talking circles.
9:12 pm
you have senators, former governors or governors, and then you had the outside class. that's 50% of the vote, by the way, over 50% of the vote is going to those three individuals. she knocked the ball out of the park. if you're thinking trump stumbled for me, i think those votes go to carly. ben carson didn't have a great night. i think those folks go to carly. i think she's going to be a big winner in this. and i thought marco rubio clearly zood out because he had such command on the issue of foreign policy in a way the other folks did not. >> i thought also chris christie i thought did well. he had a sense of personality. he was funny at times. he had what seemed like a gimmick at his opening when he said listen, don't put the camera on me, put the audience on here. and he rounded that out at the end when he said this isn't about me, it's about the person out there in this audience who's watching. it's a bit ironic, because who's a candidate who rose because of his personality. and now he's saying it's not
9:13 pm
about me, it's about the american voters. the whole concept of leaning in that women are talking about. this is what he did time and time again. you wanted the camera on her, you wanted to see the reaction, what she would do with these questions. and she often had better answers to questions than everyone else. it's almost like she was the clean-up woman in some ways. >> often times men tell women oh, you've got to smile. >> wait a minute, there was not a smile all night long. there are times to be serious, but you've got to loosen it up.
9:14 pm
>> ben carson kind of used when he said to donald trump, he's an okay doctor, just a small little line, it's a little levity that kind of shows jeb bush i think kind of humanized himself. plus she had something to prove tonight. she's a newcomer up on the big stage. i think she had to say i can hang with these people who have been up on the big stage for some time. >> i want to mention, of all the guys that did these sort of schticky answers on the dollar bill question, which is a throwaway question, but a chance to sort of -- is sshe's the onle who gave the right answer. it's a gesture, it's meaningless. they're all trying to put their moms and wives on this. i thought she really shone in that moment. >> at the heart, these are performances. and in a performance, the one thing you want to do is drive home some themes and attributes. and the theme she successfully drove home today was somebody who is clear, concise, really strong on a lot of these issues. and a greatly great command of the issue.
9:15 pm
there has to be a relatability and a likability. >> it will come. >> that will come. and there's plenty of time. >> i saw it all on twitter. i just think it's a double standard. you want to know who a real sour puss, i didn't see marco rubio smile once. nobody is criticizing marco rubio. >> michael rubio has a joke that doesn't work, he doesn't smile the whole time. carly did something extraordinary. she fought her way from the undercard, the only one that was able to do it and dominated tonight. she is going to go up. now, i agree with you, warmth is important, strength and warmth together is unstoppable. during this thing as a democrat watching this, there was a strange embrace of george w. bush. now, i said, can you please have all of them embrace george w.
9:16 pm
bush, that will help democrats a lot. but something happened tonight where george w. bush suddenly was not the radioactive name and that's weird. >> we've got to take a big break. we're going to talk to more candidates about their big night in the simi valley marathon. three hours of debate. ♪
9:17 pm
[ male announcer ] he doesn't need your help. until he does. three cylinders, 50 horsepower. go bold. go powerful. go gator. you're the marketing geniuses, what do you have planned? wow... impressive.
9:18 pm
it's even a little dangerous. yes! skycam? every guest gets a highlight reel. a highlight of what? (voice straining) not gonna sugar coat it... this one's not my favorite. to see a great idea go to for your chance to wake up in the stadium on super bowl sunday. courtyard. official hotel of the nfl. the ice is nice, but i miss the bubbles. not the same without bubbles. the possibility of a flare swas almost always on my mind. thinking about what to avoid, where to go... and how to deal with my uc. to me, that was normal. until i talked to my doctor. she told me that humira helps people like me get uc under control and keep it under control when certain medications haven't worked well enough. humira can lower your ability to fight infections, including tuberculosis. serious, sometimes fatal infections and cancers, including lymphoma, have happened; as have blood, liver, and nervous system problems, serious allergic reactions, and new or worsening heart failure.
9:19 pm
before treatment, get tested for tb. tell your doctor if you've been to areas where certain fungal infections are common, and if you've had tb, hepatitis b, are prone to infections, or have flu-like symptoms or sores. don't start humira if you have an infection. raise your expectations. ask your gastroenterologist about humira. with humira, control is possible. scott walker shared the stage tonight with ten of his rivals. allison? >> i'm here with governor walker. great to have you with us. what was your memorable moment of the night. >> i'm going to say we laid out a clear contrast. we're putting an apprentice in, someone who has never been challenged by government. i've been challenged up there on the stage and hope people saw that. and i have a big plan to repeal
9:20 pm
obama care. >> you and dr. trump mixed it up. he said that you went down the tubes. he said in iowa and in your state. and he also challenged what you said, the jobs that you created. what is your response to him now. >> using the same talking points at the democrats. i won three elections in four years in a blue state like wisconsin because we did fix things. we took a budget deficit. we cut taxes, our schools now have the second highest a.c.t. scores in the country and our budget is balanced. i can point out in contrast, mr. trump wants people to vote for him based on his business record. people should remember, he took four major projects into bankruptcy. you can't take america into bankruptcy. that's the problem with washington, too many politicians want to ask like they can take it into bankruptcy. >> what about that format? you got to mix it up right next to each other and you were trading barbs. is that awkward, were you comfortable, were you welcoming that moment?
9:21 pm
>> when i had 100,000 protester, i had people take own events about as close as we are right now getting in our face and we didn't back down. we took on the machine, we took on the washington-based special interests. i just think in the end, though, people want in the future to hear more details about what our plans are. i've got a plan to grow the economy, i've got plans to take huge chunks of the federal government and send it back to the states and the people. the more we talk about that, the better off we're going to be. >> a lot of the buzz online is carly fiorina stole the show. what did you think of her performance and exchanges with donald trump? >> i think she's impressive and the things he said about her were completely unaccept acceptable. but it's a great field of candidates out there. hopefully whomever the nominee is will pick a good number to be in the cabinet. that would be a pretty good fit, just like lincoln did, to put many of those same folks in. i think america has to see there's pretty great talent in the republican party. >> would you be willing taking a
9:22 pm
cabinet position? >> i'm working hard to earn the trust to be the one making that choice. >> did you think tonight was a break through moment? >> a lot of people have said to me at caves and diner, you're my top two candidates out there. i want to see the passion you show when you took on the union bosses and special interests. i think we showed that tonight. >> governor scott walker, thanks so much for being with us. >> we'll talk about carly fiorina, the big mark she made on that stage tonight. we'll be right back. [whirring of drones] just stay calm and move as quietly as possible. ♪ no sudden movements.
9:23 pm
♪ google search: bodega beach house. ♪ ♪ who knows, one of these kids just might be the one. to clean the oceans, to start a movement, or lead a country. it may not be obvious yet, but one of these kids is going to change the world. we just need to make sure she has what she needs. welcome to windows 10. the future starts now for all of us.
9:24 pm
gives you nexium level protection for frequent heartburn all day and all night. try nexium 24hr, the #1 prescribed acid-blocking brand, and get all day, all night protection. nexium level protection. at ally bank no branches equals great rates. it's a fact. kind of like shopping hungry equals overshopping.
9:25 pm
9:26 pm
>> we're back now with cnn's dana bash. congratulations. i nougt you both did an incredible job, as well as jake tapper. how was it out there? it's obviously very different when you're asking the questions. you're not really kind of focusing as much on in some cases some of the key moments. but for you, both of you, was there a key moment that stood
9:27 pm
out? >> the great news is there were several key moments. for me personally, my interest -- this is the question that i ask. it was kind of how jeb bush would handle this since he had gotten so attacked by donald trump as low energy. this isn't just a monday slinging situation out on the campaign trail, this hurt jeb bush, even his close aides and advisers will tell you part of his slide is because donald tru attacks have been really successful. and the bottom line is that i didn't know how he was going to answer the question i asked about what donald trump was say about his wife. and i was fascinated to know how he was going to handle it and he ended up really taking on trump, which i think he knew that he needed to do, but a lot of people were wondering if he would do it and he did. >> you were very close to carly fiorina. i think she did a standout job tonight in terms of coming with her best game on.
9:28 pm
>> she's going full thatcher. she doesn't want to be liked. she wants to be respected, listened to, she wants to make an impression on world leaders. a lot of international leaders are saying you've got assad's name wrong. so what. she's talking to assad and putin saying i'm going full thatcher. marco rubio, one moment early in the debate, we talked about responsibility for hell that is syria. and rubio wants to explain why that is not his fault. why the congress was fot going to give the president that. those are the moments i'll take away from this. >> we have that moment. >> what responsibility did the senators hold? >> i think we have three of them here. i think they had a responsibility, yes. >> we had zero responsibility. let's remember what the president said. he said the attack he was going to conduct was going to be a pin prick. the united states military was not built to conduct pin trick
9:29 pm
attacks. if the united states military is going to be engaged by a commander-in-chief, it should only be engaged by an endeavor to win. we're not going to authorize the use of form when we can't put men and women in a position to win. >> there's a lot of people who saying they definitely distinguish themselves. >> he hasn't been willing to engage in the ad hominem attacks, which worked to his benefit in this debate. he showed he's about much more than someone in their early 40s who's trying to prove he's a lot more than just a first-term senator. he's got some heft there.
9:30 pm
>> the field will bunch. a bunch of people will come up some because many different slices saw what they liked. and they will gravitate to what they liked. and there was a lot to like on that stage. i asked you earlier, did anyone have a pratt fall i didn't note? no jerry ford talking about poland, nothing like that? no memory moment for reagan in the second debate. no, everyone had a very -- i think they're all talking about the good stuff tonight. >> one thing you couldn't see on camera but we could see is how much everybody wanted in. trying to catch our eyes. >> it's often like that. it's extraordinary. the desire to get in -- >> they all know i need a moment. >> kasich wandering over to christie to have a side bar for a couple of minutes. >> as a moderator, too, it's hard to often maintain contact with them because they're all trying to look at you to get you to call on them. jake was kind of looking at
9:31 pm
their navals or somewhere just not in their eyes because you don't want to have that -- you know, have to tell them, i can't call on you right now. >> and they were all pretty cooperative. no one ran outside of their lane. no one got a false start. no one took the time. some demanded time on occasion and i think scott walker inse inserted himself very forcefully on a couple of occasions. as did carly. but generally, everyone stayed in their lanes. >> i saw some complaints online about the length of the debate. but at the same time, if it wasn't that length, with that many people on the stage, you wouldn't be able to get as substantive questions and as much exchange in which they really were able to try to -- i think all of you did an extraordinary job of trying to show the differences between these candidates which is critical. everybody who likes their position want mrs. time. i think they would still be up there if the cameras were still rolling.
9:32 pm
>> governor walker jumped in there, because he's told, you are bottoming out, dude. you've got to show that you are there. that you exist. >> do they say dude? >> i think they do say dude. or cheese head, something. >> coming up next, candidate mike huckabee joins us with his take on the night for him and his ten debating partners as well.
9:33 pm
i've spoken of the shining city all my political life. god blessed and teeming with people of all kinds... living in harmony and peace. trump: they're bringing crime. they're rapists. if i am elected they're... going to be out of there day one. reporter: do you think birth right citizenship should be ended? walker: yeah, absolutely. cruz: i think we should end birth right citizenship trump: i will build a great, great wall... in my mind it was a tall proud city built of... rocks stronger than oceans. and if there had to be city walls... the walls had doors and the doors were open to anyone with the will and the heart to get here. that's how i saw it and see it still.
9:34 pm
♪"once there was a hushpuppy" by dan romis man kind?eitlin ♪ are we good? go see. go look through their windows so you can understand their views. go find out just how kind the hes and shes of this mankind are.
9:35 pm
misswill turn anan asphalt parking lot into a new neighborhood for san franciscans. a vote for "yes" on "d" is definitely a vote for more parks and open space. a vote on proposition "d" is a vote for jobs. campos: no one is being displaced. it's 40% affordable units near the waterfront for regular people. this is just a win-win for our city. i'm behind it 100%. voting yes on "d" is so helpful to so many families in our city. without the internet i would probably be like a c student. internet essentials from comcast has brought low-cost high speed internet into the homes of hundreds of thousands of low-income families. it lets students do homework and study at home. so far more than two million people across america have benefitted. internet essentials is going to transform the lives of families. i see myself as maybe an entrepreneur. internet essentials from comcast.
9:36 pm
helping to bridge the digital divide. >> we are back here at the reagan library. the candidates and surrogates still in some cases, let's go back to allison. >> thanks so much for being with us, mike huckabee. what was the most memorable moment? >> i think it's when it was over and we got to get off our feet. it was a long three hour. a lot of elbows up on the goal. it's not really my thought that's what our debate should be. not fighting each other. it's about it felt that these are all my colleagues. gosh, huk key didn't beat up anybody. no, i'm not going to. these are my friends, my colleagues.
9:37 pm
i would pick every single one of them to be somewhere in the cabinet because they're good people. they're qualified and capable. >> were there too many people on stage? you seemed a little annoyed that it took a while to get to you pop i think it was 45 minutes into the debate before i ever got a question. those are frustrating things if you spent your whole life preparing to run for president and you're running for that office. the other side of that is i think there's a way to fix this. i'm going to suggest this. if all of the other guys would drop out and endorse me, then i will just do an interview next time. >> why didn't they think of that? >> i don't know. >> the moment has become an issue, what has happened to the kentucky county clerk kim davis. let me play for our viewers that exchange with you this evening. >> is governor bush on the wrong side of the criminalization of christianity? >> no, i don't think he's on the wrong side of such an issue. jeb is a friend. i'm not up here to fight with
9:38 pm
jeb or anybody else. but i am here to fight for somebody who is a county clerk elected under the kentucky constitution. 75% of the state voted for said marriage was between a man and a woman. we made accommodations to the detainees of gitmo. i have seen the accommodations that we made to the muslim detainees who killed americans. you're telling me that you can not make an accommodation for an elected democrat county clerk from kentucky? >> i don't believe you're stating my views right. i think there needs to be accommodation for someone acting on their faith. >> you said, quote, she is sworn to uphold the law. >> she is. so if she based on conscious can't sign that marriage license, then there should be someone in her office to be able to do it. if the law needs to be changed in the state of k ki, which is what she's advocating, it should be changed.
9:39 pm
>> this is your soul issue, it's ellipsining other things. >> no, i don't think so at all. if we don't understand the balance of pewer, separation of powers and the equality of branches and if we surrender to judicial tyranny. jefferson said you turn the constitution into a thing of wax. i think it's an issue we should talk a great deal more. a president who sur rernds the executive branch of government to the other -- to the other two, especially to the court has been derelict in his duty. he has not fulfilled his oath of office. so this issue was to me a seminal moment, when a county clerk is put in jail, not just told hey, you need to do this. put in jail. people need to remember that. and no accommodation made for her. but we made accommodations for the ft. hood shooter. we've made accommodations for the detainees at gitmo who are terrorists and killed americans. and i cannot imagine that this
9:40 pm
country cannot make some type of accommodation for kim davis. >> very quickly, you said that you would put anybody there in your cabinet. what would secretary trump be? >> it would be very difficult to limit him to one thing. but, you know, people need to realize, donald trump has a lot of gifts and talents. if donald trump were willing to serve in government, i would be more than happy to find a spot for him. i think people are underestimating his ability as a communicator. look, if you're a guy that's made $10 billion in business, you've done some things right, right? so give him his due. >> great to see you. thank so much. back to you, anderson. >> i want to go to tom forman now who has been busy fact checking some of the statements the candidates made tonight. tom? >> zond trump said so many times that he is so wealthy, you don't have to worry about him mixing money and politics. but tonight, jeb bush pushed back hard saying too late.
9:41 pm
trurp has tried to buy political influence. listen. >> you won a casino gambling in florida. you wanted it and you didn't get it because i was opposed before during and after. >> i promise if i wanted it, i would have gotten it. >> no way. not even possible. >> i know my people. >> back in the late 1990s, trump did hold a fundraiser for jeb bush when trump was trying to get a casino deal in florida. bush ultimately blocked that deal. it appears what trump is saying is false. what bush said in this issue was truth. carly fiorina took on the videotapes sperp tis s surrepti that showed planned parenthood associates trying to sell body parts from aborted fetuses.
9:42 pm
>> i dare hillary clinton, barack obama to watch these tapes. a fully formed fetus lie on the table, heart beating, legs kicking while someone is saying we have to keep it alive to harvest the brain? >> is there something that looks like that? yeah, there's actual ly a short portion that shows that's what's going on, but it was edited in. and there's no evidence that is was tied to planned parenthood. so it's true, but there it's misleading. >> it is a felony with ten years jail term. >> well, it is a crime to sell body parts, but there's no evidence that anyone is confessing to neg on these tapes. in fact, if you watch them carefully, what you hear is
9:43 pm
these representatives saying many times, this is for the handling, this is for the processing. it's less than $100 per sample. this is not a matter of profit. so for him to suggest that this is a clear confession of some sort, that is simply not true. false statement, anderson. >> all right, tom. a lot more to come in the hours and days ahead. up next, how tonight's debate played with the most important people who watched it, the voters. well, well. if it isn't the belle of the ball. gentlemen. you look well.
9:44 pm
what's new, flo? well, a name your price tool went missing last week. name your what, now? it gives you coverage options based on your budget. i just hope whoever stole it knows that it only works at so, you can't use it to just buy stuff? no. i'm sorry, gustav. we have to go back to the pet store. [ gustav squawks ] he's gonna meet us there. the name your price tool. still only at thiproof of less joint pain. and clearer skin. this is my body of proof that i can fight psoriatic arthritis from the inside out ...with humira. humira works by targeting and helping to block a specific source of inflammation that contributes to both joint and skin symptoms. it's proven to help relieve pain, stop further joint damage and clear skin in many adults. doctors have been prescribing humira for nearly 10 years. humira can lower your ability to fight infections, including tuberculosis serious,sometimes fatal infections and cancers, including lymphoma, have happened, as have blood, liver and nervous system problems,
9:45 pm
serious allergic reactions, and new or worsening heart failure. before treatment, get tested for tb. tell your doctor if you've been to areas where certain fungal infections are common, and if you've had tb, hepatitis b, are prone to infections, or have flu-like symptoms or sores. don't start humira if you have an infection. visit and talk to your rheumatologist. humira. this is a body of proof! you tuck here... you tuck there. if you're a toe tucker... because of toenail fungus, ask your doctor now about prescription kerydin. used daily, kerydin drops may kill the fungus at the site of infection and get to the root of your toe tucking. kerydin may cause irritation at the treated site. most common side effects include skin peeling... ...ingrown toenail, redness, itching, and swelling. tell your doctor if you have any side effect that bothers you or does not go away. stop toe tucking... and get the drop on toenail fungus. ask your doctor today about kerydin.
9:46 pm
>> there's some real hifts and big misses as well. >> we conducted an online dial test. specifically, we wanted to look at when self-labelled republicans and dints -- you see republicans here in red, independents in purple. very key in this primary season. we wanted to see when they
9:47 pm
agreed or disagreed what they heard in the debate. there's one moment in particular that really registered positively with them. this is how carly fiorina handled the question with jake tapper. it got very high marks as it responded. >> last week, donald trump said the following about you, quote. look at that face. would anyone vote for that. can you imagine that, the face of our next president. mr. trump later said he was talking about your persona, not your appearance. please feel free to respond what you think about his persona? >> you know, it's interesting to me. mr. trump said that he heard mr. bush clearly in what mr. bush said. i think women all over this country heard very clearly what mr. trump said. [ applause ] >> what also resonated with
9:48 pm
republicans was when fiorina talked about defunding planned parenthood. it also turns out that republican and independent dial tester, they didn't really like the testy back and fort that they saw between some of the candidates tonight. here's what they did like. this is chris christie when he was talking, and this is their response when he called out fiorina and donald trump on that back and forth and instead focused his ire on hilly clinton. >> it was is we don't want to hear about your careers, back and forth and volleying back and forth about who did well and who did poorly. you're both successful people, zblagss. you know who's not success? the middle class being plowed over by barack obama and hillary clinton. let's start talking about those issues tonight and stop talk about the childish back and forth between the two of you. >> anderson, it's really interesting, though, we really didn't see that much of it
9:49 pm
tonight, when you consider the overall picture of the debate. >> that's definitely true. we want to talk about it with our panel. it is fascinating to see that dial testing, and that exchange where chris christie really turned the bickering between donald trump and carly fiorina to criticize hillary clinton and support for the middle class. carly fiorina stood up for herself and came back and said you talked a lot about your record, we're talk about our record and it's a valid question of leadership. >> chris christie's strategy was if he knew there was one unifying theme, it's go after hillary clinton. but carly fiorina, yeah, i think she did try to use it to her advantage as well. so it ended up being a positive exchange for both of them. >> the go after hillary clinton
9:50 pm
thing, ho gave this very bizarre defense of why he will not take on hillary clinton until, i guess, the general, which makes zero sense. of course, he should be criticizing hillary clinton and her policies. he had a great night on the first debate and i think really fell flat on this one. >> i think kasich, you saw the biggest contract, beautiful in his home state and hometown crowd. you put him here, he just was not memorable. i thought one thing she had got a lot of credit for, carly, since it was clearly her night. when she talked about the drug policy issue, that's something a lot of republicans backed away from. i thought it was an important moment for the party. but carly talked about her kid dying. and that was powerful. >> let's play that. >> my husband frank and i buried a child to drug addiction. so we must invest more in the
9:51 pm
treatment of drug. i agree with senator paul, i agree with states rights, but we are misleading young people when we tell them that marijuana is just like having a beer. it's not. and the marijuana that kids are smoking today is not the same as the marijuana that jeb bush smoked 40 years ago. we do -- sorry. >> as far as we know. >> we do need criminal justice reform. drug addiction is an epidemic. and it is taking too many of our young people. i know this sadly from personal experience. >> again, her ability not just to talk about issues but also to reveal something very intensely personal. >> i think in some ways synthesize everyone else's answers and make it better, right? she was personal, i thought. she was a compassionate conservative. she was also law and order. that original question was supposed to go to jeb bush because it was a tete-a-tete
9:52 pm
between jeb bush and rand paul. and she stepped in and said guys, this is how it's done. >> rand paul touted his libertarianism and made a lot of sense in parts of the country where they don't vote in republican primaries. both boots on the ground issue. every time we open a base, we're not necessarily making ourself safer. i'm not so sure that plays well with the gop base. and also the way in which he spoke about marijuana and medical marijuana. and then chris tis christie said he would enforce the federal law against state law. everyone playing to their strength in that regard. >> in that exchange, this is when carly looked like the adult on the stage that we've been missing for a lot of these debates and certainly for the first half of the debate. a, she personalized it and b, she didn't take the base with the whole face question with trump. real classy 37. >> not only did she personalize it, she localized it.
9:53 pm
there's an epidemic in new hampshire. where is carly fiorina starting to grow her support? in a place like new hampshire. >> two things about it, i think she's exactly where most parents are. i'm against drug use for my children. but if they make a mistake, i don't want them to go to prison. and she laned right there. >> we've got to take a quick break. stay with us. i want to get some of the final thoughts about tonight's debate when we come back. the official hotel of super bowl 50, you're the marketing geniuses, what do you have planned? wow... impressive. it's even a little dangerous. yes! skycam? every guest gets a highlight reel. a highlight of what? (voice straining) not gonna sugar coat it... this one's not my favorite. to see a great idea go to for your chance to wake up in the stadium on super bowl sunday. courtyard. official hotel of the nfl. the ice is nice, but i miss the bubbles. not the same without bubbles. brand sleep deprived. .
9:54 pm
bring us those who want to feel well rested and ready to enjoy the morning ahead aleve pm. the first to combine a safe sleep aid... plus the 12 hour pain relieving strength of aleve. for pain relief that can last until the am. so you... you... and you, can be a morning person again. aleve pm for a better am. now available with an easy open cap.
9:55 pm
take a look at these bbq best cracked pepper sauce... most ribs eaten while calf roping... yep, greatness deserves recognition. you got any trophies, cowboy? ♪ whoomp there it is uh, yeah... well, uh, well there's this one. best insurance mobile app? yeah, two years in a row. well i'll be... does that thing just follow you around? like a little puppy! the award-winning geico app. download it today.
9:56 pm
i was going to the library to do my homework. it was a little bit of a walk to get to the bus stop. i had to wait in line to use the computer. took a lot of juggling to keep it all together. what's possible when you have high-speed internet at home? the library never closes. it makes it so much better to do homework when you're at home. internet essentials from comcast. helping to bridge the digital divide.
9:57 pm
>> rand paul and donald traufum trading jabs. >> first of all, rand paul shouldn't be on this stage. he's number 11. he has 1% in the polls. there's far too many people up here anyway. >> i have to laugh. he was asked whether or not he would be capable and if he would be in good hands and be in charge of the nuclear weapon then all of a sudden there's a sideways attack at me. i think his visceral response to attack people on their appearance, short, tall, fat, ugly. my goodness, that happened in junior high. are we not way above that? should we not all be worried to have someone like that in charge with the nuclear arsenal. >> i never attacked him on his
9:58 pm
look and believe me, there's plenty of subject matter right there. that i can tell you. >> let's get some quick final thoughts. >> in the museum in to which i toured, there's a display case ronald reagan 3 by 5 cards he wrote one-liners he wrote in dinner speeches. i wrote this down, never start an argument with a woman when she's tired or when she's rested. that's a lesson donald trump should have paid attention to carly fiorina. >> i think the rnc owes carly fiorina a big fat check because she did a lot of the dirty work at sort of leveling and really deflating donald trump in this deba debate. he said his code name would be humble at the end of this debate. and he was very much humbled i thought by carly fiorina. she's about 3% in the polls against donald trump. but it will be interested to see how this polls. >> the other candidates showed h
9:59 pm
he cthey can take him on in a debate. carly presented herself as a presidential candidate. she looked presidential, she sounded presidential. i would watch for her. >> i agree with that, absolutely. i think the trend line to watch now is where do carly fiorina's numbers go in these early contests. and the other really important trend line, does this affect her fundraising? is there a bunch of small dollar donors that start flowing her way. >> i would submit one of the losers was probably ben carson who had a really tough time to answer some questions, as i assumed he would, particularly his line about 9/11 and wanting to meet that with a bully pulpit into going into what even obama called a necessary war. >> as a democrat watch, did not see very much discussion about the economy at all, except as an excuse to not do anything about climate change. here in california with half the state on fire, i thought that was in poor form. >> i want to thank everybody. the reminder, the democrat's
10:00 pm
first faceoff come next month. we're going to be bringing it to you. i'll be moderating that on october 13. that's the date in the cnn facebook debate. las vegas the place we're all looking forward to. that does it for us. thank you very much for watching. right now, an encore edition of tonight's debate. i'll see you tomorrow. and pains. not tylenol. not aleve. nothing. relief doesn't get any better than this. advil. [whirring of drones] just stay calm and move as quietly as possible. ♪ no sudden movements. ♪ google search: bodega beach house. ♪ ♪
10:01 pm
[ male announcer ] he doesn't need your help. until he does. three cylinders, 50 horsepower. go bold. go powerful. go gator. go bold. go powerful. who knows, one of these kids just might be the one. to clean the oceans, to start a movement, or lead a country. it may not be obvious yet, but one of these kids is going to change the world. we just need to make sure she has what she needs. welcome to windows 10. the future starts now for all of us.
10:02 pm
at ally bank no branches equalsit's a fact.. kind of like mute buttons equal danger. ...that sound good? not being on this phone call sounds good. it's not muted. was that you jason? it was geoffrey! it was jason. it could've been brenda. i'god blessed and teeming with citpeople of all kinds...e. living in harmony and peace. trump: they're bringing crime. they're rapists. if i am elected they're... going to be out of there day one. reporter: do you think birth right citizenship should be ended? walker: yeah, absolutely. cruz: i think we should end birth right citizenship trump: i will build a great, great wall... in my mind it was a tall proud city built of... rocks stronger than oceans. and if there had to be city walls... the walls had doors and the doors were open to anyone
10:03 pm
with the will and the heart to get here. that's how i saw it and see it still. ♪"once there was a hushpuppy" by dan romis man kind?eitlin ♪ are we good? go see. go look through their windows so you can understand their views. go find out just how kind the hes and shes of this mankind are.